Lemon Custard Squares served in a styled dish.

Preview: built by our recipe engine and not yet reviewed. Details may change.

Lemon Custard Squares

Yield
24 servings

A buttery flour base supports a baked lemon and egg filling that is cut into squares after cooling.

Ingredients
Show the recipe for

Tips are one tap away.

Ingredients

Servings
Units
Batches and reset

24 servings · US measures · 1 batch

Batching

Bake one 9-by-13-inch pan per batch. For 48 squares, bake a second pan. Baking and cooling times do not change with the amount; a half batch is not offered because it needs a different pan size.

Original recipe: 24 servings.

There are no optional ingredients in this edition.

Open shopping list

Before you start

  • Read through the recipe before you start; the squares need to cool completely before cutting. Gather the pan, two bowls, whisk, spoon, wire rack, knife, thermometer and the measured ingredients.

Directions

1

Read and gather

For the whole recipe

Read through the recipe and gather the equipment. Use the ingredient lines to prepare and measure everything, and let the butter soften on the counter. Do not taste the raw crust dough or the raw filling; they contain raw flour, and the filling raw egg. Everything is measured and the butter is soft.

2

Heat the oven

For each pan

Heat the oven to 350°F with a rack in the middle. The oven is heating.

3

Mix the crust and press it into the pan

For each pan

Mix about 2 cups all-purpose flour, about 1 cup butter and about 1/2 cup sugar in a medium bowl until it forms a crumbly dough that holds together when you pinch it. Press it evenly over the bottom of the 9-by-13-inch baking pan. The crust is pressed into an even layer.

4

Bake the crust

For each pan

Bake the crust on a rack in the middle at 350°F until it is firm and golden at the edges, about 15 minutes.

5

Whisk the lemon filling

For each pan

Whisk about 1 1/2 cups sugar and about 1/4 cup all-purpose flour in the second bowl, then whisk in 4 whole large eggs and the lemon juice until the filling is smooth.

6

Pour the filling over the crust and bake

For each pan

Pour the filling over the hot crust and bake on a rack in the middle at 350°F until the filling is set and no longer jiggles in the center, about 20 minutes. An instant-read thermometer in the center of the filling reads 160°F (71°C).

7

Cool the pan completely

For each pan

Cool the pan on the wire rack until it is at room temperature all the way through and the filling is firm, about 1 to 2 hours.

8

Cut into squares and serve

For the whole recipe

Cut into even squares with a sharp knife, wiping the blade between cuts, to make 24 servings. Taste a corner piece. Aim for bright, tart lemon balanced by sweetness, on a crisp base. If it tastes too sharp, chill the squares before serving, which softens the tartness. Refrigerate leftovers, covered. The squares are cut and ready to serve.

About this recipe

Research preview: these details come from our sourced research and haven't been reviewed by our chef yet.

Why it works

Baking the pressed shortbread base first sets it firm, so the liquid lemon filling cannot soak in. A little flour in the filling helps the eggs set it into a sliceable custard, and cooling completely lets it firm before cutting.

Associated with

American

Lemon bars draw on British lemon curd and Scottish shortbread. The first widely printed recipe appeared in a Chicago newspaper in 1962, though community cookbooks carried similar bars earlier.

Taste

  • Sweet
  • Sour
  • Salty
  • Bitter
  • Savory
  • Heat

Bright lemon and plenty of sugar in balance., Rich butter crust. · buttery shortbread base, smooth, set lemon custard · cold

Skill level

Easy

Two short bakes and simple mixing; the main judgment is when the filling is set.

You'll practice: Press a shortbread base into a pan, Bake a base before filling it, Whisk an egg and lemon filling, Judge when a custard is set, Cool fully before cutting

Allergens

Contains: milk, egg, wheat.

Diets

Vegetarian: Fits as listed Vegan: Doesn't fit as written Pescatarian: Fits as listed Dairy: See the allergen lines Egg: See the allergen lines Gluten: See the allergen lines

Occasions

  • Lemon bar day · Informal food day

    An informal food day dedicated to lemon bars.

    October 15 each year (informal, not maintained by any authority)

  • Spring and Easter dessert tables · Editorial fit

    A bright, make-ahead bar that cuts into many pieces.

Course: dessert · Technique: bake · Time: 1-to-2-hours, make-ahead, long-unattended-wait

Serving and keeping

Best served: Once completely cool and set Cut into 24 squares, dusted with powdered sugar if you like

Make ahead: Cool, cover and refrigerate; cut when firm.

Storage: An egg-set filling: refrigerate covered within 2 hours of cooling. The time follows federal guidance for egg dishes.

Leftovers: Keep refrigerated and eat within 3 to 4 days.

Food safety

  • Do not taste the raw crust dough or the raw filling: they contain raw flour and raw eggs.
  • Refrigerate the cooled squares within 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90 °F (32 °C).

We make no statement about cross-contact in your kitchen or in packaged ingredients. Check the flour and butter labels.

Nutrition notes

Mostly sugar, butter and flour; a single square is a small dessert portion.

Butter in the base supplies most of the saturated fat.

We don't show nutrition claims (like “good source of”) until our legal review is done.

For your food tracker

Fields for MyFitnessPal and other trackers
Recipe url
https://isthebestrecipe.com/desserts/lemon-custard-squares
Name
Lemon Custard Squares
Servings
24
Recipe yield
24 servings
Recipe ingredient
about 2 cups all-purpose flour for the crust, spooned and leveled, about 1 cup butter softened, about 1/2 cup sugar for the crust, about 1 1/2 cups sugar for the filling, about 1/4 cup all-purpose flour for the filling, 4 whole large eggs, 2 whole lemons juiced
Nutrition information
Nutrient 1008
187.77
Nutrient 1003
2.35
Nutrient 1004
8.59
Nutrient 1005
25.95
Nutrient 1079
0.33
Nutrient 2000
16.80
Nutrient 1093
73.09
Nutrient 1258
5.14
Nutrient 1253
51.34
Nutrient 1087
9.10
Nutrient 1089
0.70
Nutrient 1092
30.76
Nutrient 1114
0.17
Nutrient 1259
0.31
Nutrient 1260
0.19
Nutrient 1262
0.24
Nutrient 1271
0.02
Nutrient 1276
0.00
Nutrient 1277
0.01
Nutrient 1279
0.00
Nutrient 1261
0.11
Nutrient 1263
0.24
Nutrient 1264
0.71
Nutrient 1272
<0.01
Nutrient 1275
0.11
Nutrient 1278
0.00
Nutrient 1280
<0.01
Nutrient 1110
6.83
Nutrient 1180
27.68
Nutrient 1018
0.00
Nutrient 1105
76.80
Nutrient 1057
0.00
Nutrient 1058
0.00
Nutrient 1190
39.10
Nutrient 1062
785.36
Nutrient 1185
0.72
Nutrient 1242
0.00
Nutrient 1246
0.00
Nutrient 1090
4.01
Nutrient 1091
31.75
Nutrient 1098
0.02
Nutrient 1101
0.08
Nutrient 1007
0.35
Nutrient 1162
1.55
Nutrient 1165
0.10
Nutrient 1166
0.10
Nutrient 1178
0.09
Nutrient 1051
12.97
Nutrient 1095
0.20
Nutrient 1167
0.71
Nutrient 1170
0.19
Nutrient 1175
0.02
Nutrient 1292
2.30
Nutrient 1293
0.50
Nutrient 1265
2.26
Nutrient 1266
1.01
Nutrient 1268
2.18
Nutrient 1269
0.43
Nutrient 1270
0.04
Nutrient 1187
8.40
Nutrient 1177
26.45
Nutrient 1120
0.91
Nutrient 1122
0.00
Nutrient 1106
78.03
Nutrient 1107
14.98
Nutrient 1108
0.00
Nutrient 1104
281.60
Nutrient 1186
18.05
Nutrient 1109
0.32
Nutrient 1123
44.63
Nutrient 1103
6.73
Copy action wording
Copy recipe and estimated nutrition
Sources

Make it the best

Copy this recipe and make it your own. Change amounts, swap ingredients, rewrite steps. The original stays as it is.

Nutrition Values

Estimated · Per serving · 190 kcal

Estimated macro energy share
MacroGramsShare
Carbohydrate25.95 g54.48%
Fat8.59 g40.58%
Protein2.35 g4.94%

Shortbread crust with salted butter and a baked lemon-egg filling, cut into 24 squares

Nutrition details

Shortbread crust with salted butter and a baked lemon-egg filling, cut into 24 squares

Main nutrients

Per serving

Calories
187.77 kcal
Protein
2.35 g
Carbohydrates
25.95 g
Fiber
0.33 g
Total sugars
16.80 g
Total fat
8.59 g
Saturated fat
5.14 g
Sodium
73.09 mg
Vitamins and minerals

Per serving

Calcium, Ca
9.10 mg
Iron, Fe
0.70 mg
Potassium, K
30.76 mg
Vitamin D (D2 + D3)
0.17 µg
Vitamin D (D2 + D3), International Units
6.83 IU
Choline, total
27.68 mg
Retinol
76.80 µg
Folate, DFE
39.10 µg
Vitamin K (phylloquinone)
0.72 µg
Vitamin E, added
0.00 mg
Vitamin B-12, added
0.00 µg
Magnesium, Mg
4.01 mg
Phosphorus, P
31.75 mg
Copper, Cu
0.02 mg
Vitamin C, total ascorbic acid
1.55 mg
Thiamin
0.10 mg
Riboflavin
0.10 mg
Vitamin B-12
0.09 µg
Zinc, Zn
0.20 mg
Niacin
0.71 mg
Pantothenic acid
0.19 mg
Vitamin B-6
0.02 mg
Folate, food
8.40 µg
Folate, total
26.45 µg
Cryptoxanthin, beta
0.91 µg
Lycopene
0.00 µg
Vitamin A, RAE
78.03 µg
Carotene, beta
14.98 µg
Carotene, alpha
0.00 µg
Vitamin A, IU
281.60 IU
Folic acid
18.05 µg
Vitamin E (alpha-tocopherol)
0.32 mg
Lutein + zeaxanthin
44.63 µg
Selenium, Se
6.73 µg
Other nutrients

Per serving

Cholesterol
51.34 mg
SFA 4:0
0.31 g
SFA 6:0
0.19 g
SFA 10:0
0.24 g
PUFA 20:4
0.02 g
PUFA 18:4
0.00 g
MUFA 20:1
0.01 g
MUFA 22:1
0.00 g
SFA 8:0
0.11 g
SFA 12:0
0.24 g
SFA 14:0
0.71 g
PUFA 22:6 n-3 (DHA)
<0.01 g
MUFA 16:1
0.11 g
PUFA 20:5 n-3 (EPA)
0.00 g
PUFA 22:5 n-3 (DPA)
<0.01 g
Alcohol, ethyl
0.00 g
Caffeine
0.00 mg
Theobromine
0.00 mg
Energy
785.36 kJ
Manganese, Mn
0.08 mg
Ash
0.35 g
Water
12.97 g
Fatty acids, total monounsaturated
2.30 g
Fatty acids, total polyunsaturated
0.50 g
SFA 16:0
2.26 g
SFA 18:0
1.01 g
MUFA 18:1
2.18 g
PUFA 18:2
0.43 g
PUFA 18:3
0.04 g
Incomplete data

Unknown source coverage is not zero.

Calculation details

An estimate, not a laboratory analysis or regulatory nutrition label.

Calculated from retained ingredient source mappings; independent review pending.

Estimated from protein and carbohydrate at 4 kcal/g and fat at 9 kcal/g. This is not a breakdown of reported Calories; food-specific factors and carbohydrate composition can differ. Rounded percentages may not total exactly 100%; segments use exact shares.

Per serving: calculated macro energy 190.49 kcal; reported Calories 187.77 kcal. Difference: 2.72 kcal.

USDA FoodData Central

Use in MyFitnessPal

Use the selected recipe amounts and servings when creating your recipe in MyFitnessPal. Its ingredient matches may give different estimates.

Your notes

Kept on this device.

Share recipe

Lemon Custard Squares